The Broken People Were Always the Story

I only meant to take a break.

I had been working, thinking, writing, doing all the usual things that keep my brain running long after it should have stopped, and I decided I needed to put something on television and switch off for a while.
So I went back to Doom Patrol.
I had not watched it in some time, and somewhere in the middle of that rewatch I had one of those strange moments where something familiar suddenly looks completely different.
Not because the show had changed.
Because I had.
I started noticing how much of it had stayed with me.
Not plot points. Not characters I had consciously borrowed from. Not scenes I had recreated elsewhere.
Something deeper than that.
A way of looking at people.
A way of deciding who deserves to be at the centre of a story.
Doom Patrol is full of people who are damaged, difficult, ridiculous, selfish, frightened, angry, traumatised, loving, cruel, funny, heroic, pathetic and contradictory.
Often all at once.
They do not have one revelation and become healthy.
They do not learn a lesson and stop making mistakes.
They regress.
They lash out.
They know better and still do the wrong thing.
They love each other and are still occasionally terrible to each other.
And the story keeps insisting that they matter anyway.
Watching it again, I suddenly realised how much permission there was in that.
Not imitation.
Permission.
Sometimes influence is not a character you recreate or a plot you adapt.
Sometimes influence is somebody else making a story that quietly tells you:
You are allowed to write people like this.
You are allowed to make them this damaged.
This strange.
This contradictory.
You are allowed to let them stay unfinished.
And you are still allowed to ask the audience to care about them.
That realisation hit me harder than I expected.
Then I reached Danny the Street.
And that was where it stopped being an interesting observation about writing and became something much more personal.
There is a musical sequence built around Danny that I remembered liking the first time around.
On this rewatch, I nearly cried.
At first I felt faintly ridiculous about that.
Then I understood why.
Danny represents something deceptively simple: a place where people who have spent their lives feeling wrong can exist without first becoming acceptable.
A place where being strange is not a problem to solve.
Where being damaged is not grounds for exclusion.
Where people who have spent their lives outside can walk in and find music, colour, laughter, community and other people who understand what it is to be there.
I want to be careful here, because Danny also has a very real and very important connection to queer people, gender nonconformity, drag, and people whose identities have made them targets.
I am not pretending those experiences are mine.
I am a middle-aged, heterosexual white man. I have never had to navigate the particular dangers or exclusions that come with being gay, trans, gender-nonconforming, or visibly queer.
Those experiences belong to the people who live them.
But Danny is not only about those identities.
There is an emotional idea underneath the specificity that reaches further:
the feeling that there is something about you that makes ordinary belonging difficult.
The feeling that you are too strange.
Too damaged.
Too inconvenient.
Too wrong.
Too much.
Or somehow not enough.
That part I know.
I have known it for years.
The feeling of being outside.
The feeling that something about you does not quite fit the shape the world seems to expect.
The feeling that belonging is conditional.
That there has to be some reason you are allowed to stay.
That usefulness might be the price of admission.
And suddenly the Danny the Street sequence was not just a joyful scene in a superhero show.
It was the fantasy of somewhere that simply says:
Come in.
Not when you are better.
Not when you have fixed yourself.
Not once you have become easier to deal with.
Now.
As you are.
And then I had another realisation.
I looked at what I have been writing.
Especially A Funeral for the Living.
And I saw it.
Not consciously.
I never sat down and thought, “I am going to take something from Doom Patrol and put it into a fantasy trilogy.”
I was not thinking about Danny when I built Titan.
I was not thinking about the Doom Patrol when I wrote Elias, Jack, Ethan, Nathan, Riley, or any of the others.
But on the rewatch, I suddenly recognised the same emotional question sitting underneath them.
What happens to the people the world has decided are finished?
The failed people.
The discarded people.
The forgotten people.
The people who no longer fit the role they were supposed to play.
The people who carry damage that does not disappear simply because the story would be more convenient if they were functional now.
What if they still matter?
What if they are still allowed purpose?
Dignity?
Humour?
Anger?
Contradiction?
Love?
Even heroism?
And then the sentence arrived fully formed in my head:
They are my Doom Patrol.
Not copies.
Not analogues.
Not fantasy versions of those characters.
My version of the same tribe.
Broken people who have been told, directly or indirectly, that they do not fit.
People who keep going anyway.
People who find one another.
People who hurt one another.
People who feed one another.
People who make mistakes.
People who fail.
People who stay damaged.
People who still choose what they do next.
That last part matters to me.
I do not think I write stories about broken people becoming unbroken.
I do not believe that is how most of us work.
Damage changes us.
Grief changes us.
Failure changes us.
Trauma changes us.
Sometimes permanently.
The more interesting question, to me, is what someone does after that.
Whether there is still a life after the thing that changed them.
Whether there is still a place at the table.
Whether being broken disqualifies someone from belonging.
Whether usefulness is the same thing as worth.
Whether a person still matters once the world has decided their useful years are behind them.
Those questions are everywhere in my writing.
I did not realise until now how much Doom Patrol had once given me a vocabulary for a kind of humanity I was already carrying.
That may be the strangest thing about influence.
Sometimes you know exactly where something came from.
You can point to the book, song, film, game or person that changed the way you think.
Other times it disappears into you.
It sits there for years.
You forget about it.
You write different stories in different worlds with different people.
And then one day you go back to the thing that once mattered to you and suddenly recognise yourself staring back.
That is what happened to me.
I put on Doom Patrol because I wanted a break.
Instead, I found a piece of the answer to why I write the people I do.
The damaged parts are not edited out of the story.
They are not obstacles the characters have to overcome before the real story can begin.
They are the story.
And maybe that is what I have been trying to say all along.
Not that broken people can become worthy again.
That they never stopped being worthy in the first place.

Comments